Why lawyers cannot reply like other businesses
A restaurant owner can answer a bad review with details: the order, the time, what the server remembers. A lawyer usually cannot. The facts of a representation are confidential, and that duty does not end because a former client posted something online.
ABA Model Rule 1.6 protects information relating to the representation of a client. It is broader than attorney-client privilege. It covers facts that may seem harmless, including the fact that the person was a client at all, unless the client has made that public or consents.
Disciplinary cases across several states show what happens when lawyers forget this. Lawyers have been sanctioned for replying to reviews with details about the client's case, conduct or payment history. The pattern is consistent: an angry reply, a few revealing facts, then a bar complaint that is much worse than the review.
Reviews still matter for marketing. Ratings and review content appear next to your firm in Google Maps and the local pack, and prospects read them before they call. Our guide to local SEO and reviews covers why. The goal is to protect that reputation without creating an ethics problem.
The pressure to reply also comes from inside the firm. Partners worry that silence looks like guilt. In practice, prospects reading reviews tend to weigh the overall pattern and the tone of any replies. A measured, generic response often reads better than a detailed defense, even a fair one.
What ABA Formal Opinion 496 says
In January 2021 the ABA Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility issued Formal Opinion 496, which deals directly with lawyers responding to online criticism. It is an advisory opinion, not a binding rule, but it reflects how many state bars approach the issue.
The main points, in plain terms:
- A negative review alone does not permit disclosure. Rule 1.6 has a self-defense exception, but the opinion concludes that a public online review is generally not the kind of controversy that exception covers.
- Lawyers may choose not to respond. Silence is often the safest option, and it does not admit anything.
- A response, if any, should not reveal confidential information. The opinion suggests that a short reply saying professional obligations prevent a detailed response may be appropriate.
- Inviting the reviewer to talk offline is acceptable, as long as the invitation itself reveals nothing.
- Reviews from non-clients raise fewer confidentiality concerns, but a careful, accurate reply is still wise.
You can read the opinion and related resources on the ABA's professional responsibility pages. Your own state's rules and ethics opinions control, and some states have issued their own guidance. This post is general information, not legal advice.
Reply templates that reveal nothing
A good public reply is short, calm and generic. It shows prospective clients that the firm is professional, without confirming who the reviewer is or what happened. Write it once, have a partner approve it and reuse it.
When the reviewer may be a client or former client
Thank you for your feedback. Our professional obligations prevent us from discussing any client matter in a public forum. If you would like to talk, please call our office and ask for the managing partner.
When you have no record of the person
We take every comment seriously. We could not find a record that matches this review. If we have missed something, please contact our office directly so we can look into it.
Be careful with the second template. Saying "this person was never our client" is fine only when you are certain. If there is any chance the person was a prospective client, Rule 1.18 also imposes confidentiality duties, and a vaguer reply is safer.
What not to write
- Any detail about the case, the outcome, fees or the client's behavior.
- Phrases like "as you know" or "despite our advice" that hint at the matter.
- Arguments, sarcasm or a point-by-point rebuttal.
- Threats of legal action against the reviewer.
Read every reply once more before posting and ask one question: could a stranger learn anything about this person's legal matter from it? If yes, cut it.
Take the conversation offline
Many negative reviews come from people who felt unheard. A private call can resolve the concern, and sometimes the reviewer updates or removes the review on their own. That outcome is far better than any public reply.
A few guardrails for the offline conversation:
- Let a senior person call. A partner or office manager signals that the firm takes the complaint seriously.
- Listen before explaining. Many reviewers want acknowledgment more than a remedy.
- Do not ask for removal as a condition of a refund or any other benefit. Trading something of value for a changed review crosses into incentive territory and can raise ethics concerns.
- Document the call in the client file, as you would any client communication.
If the issue was real, fix it. Common themes in legal reviews are slow callbacks, unclear fees and surprise at how long a case takes. Those are process problems. Our post on intake speed covers the first one, and clearer engagement letters often help with the second.
If the reviewer is a current client, think about the representation itself. A public complaint can signal a breakdown in the relationship that needs attention well beyond marketing.
When to flag a review to Google
Google will not remove a review because it is unfair, harsh or one-sided. It may remove a review that breaks its policies for user-contributed content. Know the difference before you report anything.
Reviews that may qualify for removal include:
- Spam or fake engagement, such as reviews posted by bots or by someone who was never a customer.
- Conflicts of interest, such as a review from a competitor or a former employee.
- Off-topic content that does not describe an experience with the firm.
- Harassment, hate speech, threats or sexually explicit content.
- Personal information, such as someone's phone number or address.
To report a review, use the reviews section of your Google Business Profile or the review management tool Google provides. Choose the policy that best fits and keep a record of the date and reason. Google may take days or weeks to decide, and it does not always agree.
Do not report a review just to make it disappear. Mass flagging of legitimate reviews tends to fail, and it wastes time you could spend earning new ones. Never ask friends, staff or vendors to post counter-reviews. That violates Google's policies and may break bar rules on misleading communications.
Other platforms have their own rules and reporting tools. Avvo, Yelp and legal directories each publish content guidelines, and their standards differ from Google's. Read the relevant policy before reporting, and keep your reply approach the same everywhere, because the confidentiality duty does not change with the website.
Build a steady flow of genuine reviews
One negative review among a few hundred positive ones barely registers. The same review among five total dominates the profile. The long-term answer is volume and freshness from real clients.
Build review requests into the end of every matter:
- Ask in person or by phone when the client expresses satisfaction.
- Follow up with a short email or text that includes your direct review link.
- Make the request once, maybe with one reminder. Do not pressure.
- Ask every client the same way, not only those you expect to be happy.
That last point matters. Google's policies prohibit selectively soliciting positive reviews, sometimes called review gating. A survey that sends happy clients to Google and unhappy ones to a private form is a common example.
Never offer anything of value for a review. That means no discounts, gift cards, donations in the client's name or raffle entries. Google bans incentivized reviews, and ABA Model Rule 7.2 generally prohibits giving anything of value for recommending a lawyer's services. Our Google Business Profile checklist covers the rest of your profile hygiene.
Remember that a review request also touches confidentiality. Some clients will not want to be publicly associated with a criminal or family matter. Make it easy to decline, and never post a client's name or story yourself without written consent.
Timing helps. Ask soon after a good moment, such as a favorable result or a closed matter, while the experience is fresh. Requests sent months later get fewer replies, and the reviews that do arrive tend to be shorter and less specific.
A simple policy your firm can adopt
Reviews become emotional when nobody owns them. A one-page policy removes guesswork and keeps individual lawyers from replying in anger late at night.
- Owner. Name one person, usually the managing partner or marketing lead, who approves every public reply.
- Monitoring. Check Google, Avvo, Yelp and any other relevant sites weekly, or use alerts.
- Waiting period. Wait at least a day before replying to any negative review.
- Approved templates. Use pre-approved replies only. Anything new needs a second reader.
- Escalation. Threats, defamation concerns or reviews tied to active matters go to the managing partner, and possibly to outside ethics counsel.
- Positive reviews. A short thank-you is fine, but avoid confirming the case type or outcome.
- Review requests. One consistent process for every closed matter, with no incentives.
Revisit the policy once a year, or when your state bar issues new guidance. Discussions on The Managing Partners Podcast often return to the same lesson: reputation is built through client service over years, not won in a reply box.
Train everyone, not just partners. Paralegals and intake staff often see reviews first and may feel protective of the firm. A short briefing on the policy and the reasons behind it prevents a well-meaning staff reply that reveals more than anyone intended.




