Advertising

Advertising ethicsMarketing a law firm inside the rules

Every ad, page and post your firm publishes is a communication about legal services. The ethics rules apply to all of it, and the strictest state you practice in sets the bar.

By the Array Law editorsUpdated Nov 10, 20269 min read
Advertising ethics illustration
7.1
no false or misleading communications
7.2(c)
limits on specialist claims
7.3
restricts live solicitation

Key takeaways

  • Model Rule 7.1 is the core test: no false or misleading communication about the firm or its services.
  • Past results, testimonials and comparisons are the most common traps. Context and disclaimers matter.
  • Avoid calling anyone a specialist or expert unless your state's rules allow it.
  • States differ. Texas, Florida and New York add filing, labeling or disclaimer duties. This is not legal advice.

Start with the framework

The ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct are a template. They are not binding on their own. Each state adopts its own version, sometimes word for word and sometimes with significant changes. When we refer to a rule number below, check your state's version before relying on it. Nothing here is legal advice, and your state bar's ethics counsel or hotline is the right place for specific questions.

In 2018 the ABA simplified its advertising rules. Former Rules 7.4 and 7.5 were folded into the remaining rules, leaving three that do most of the work:

  • Rule 7.1 prohibits false or misleading communications about the lawyer or the lawyer's services.
  • Rule 7.2 covers advertising specifically, including payments for recommendations, specialist claims and the requirement to include a responsible lawyer's or firm's name and contact information.
  • Rule 7.3 restricts solicitation, especially live person-to-person contact with someone the lawyer knows needs legal services, when a significant motive is the lawyer's financial gain.

Rule 8.4(a) adds an important point for marketing. You cannot do through others what you cannot do yourself. That includes your marketing vendors, intake staff and anyone posting on the firm's behalf. The ABA publishes the current Model Rules and comments online, and they are worth reading in full once.

What misleading means in practice

Rule 7.1 reaches beyond outright false statements. A statement that is literally true can still be misleading if it leaves out a fact needed to make the overall message accurate, or if it creates unjustified expectations.

Patterns that often raise concern on law firm websites and ads:

  • Superlatives you cannot prove. "The best injury firm in Ohio" or "the toughest defense lawyers" are comparisons that usually cannot be factually substantiated.
  • Implied guarantees. "We win" or "get the money you deserve" can suggest an outcome no lawyer can promise.
  • Inflated size or reach. Listing offices that are not staffed, or using stock photos of a large team when the firm has two lawyers, can mislead about who will handle the matter.
  • Fee claims with hidden conditions. "No fee unless we win" can be misleading if clients may still owe costs. Say who pays expenses.
  • Unearned awards. Badges from paid directories or pay-to-play "top lawyer" lists can mislead if the basis for the award is not clear. Some states regulate how such recognitions may be described.

A simple editorial test helps. Would a reasonable prospect, reading this claim quickly on a phone, come away with a belief that is not true? If yes, rewrite it. Plain, specific statements tend to be both safer and more persuasive than slogans, something we see across the strongest law firm websites we review.

Watch visual claims as well as words. A photo of a courtroom on a page for a firm that settles every case, a fake news-style layout, or a gavel graphic next to a guarantee can all add to an overall impression that the text alone would not create. Regulators look at the whole communication, not just individual sentences.

Past results and case values

Results are the most tempting content a firm has. They are also the most sensitive. The comments to Model Rule 7.1 note that truthful reports of past results can still mislead if presented in a way that leads people to expect similar results without reference to the specific facts of their own case.

Practical ways firms handle this:

  • Add context. Explain what kind of case it was and what made the outcome possible, rather than listing dollar figures alone.
  • Use a clear disclaimer near the results, stating that past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Some states require specific wording.
  • Show net and gross honestly if your state requires it, or avoid figures that hide large fees and costs.
  • Get client consent. Publishing a result can reveal information relating to the representation. Rule 1.6 confidentiality applies, so get informed consent before you post identifiable details.
  • Keep the file. Retain documentation that supports each published result.

Never publish a result you cannot verify, and never round up. A results page with a few well-explained matters builds more trust than a long scroll of numbers.

Specialist, expert and similar words

Model Rule 7.2(c) says a lawyer should not state or imply certification as a specialist in a particular field unless certified by an organization approved by the state or accredited by the ABA, and the certifying organization is clearly named in the communication.

That has direct effects on marketing copy:

  • "Board-certified in family law by [named organization]" may be fine if accurate and allowed in your state.
  • "Family law specialist" without certification is risky in most states.
  • "Expert" is treated differently across states. Some view it as implying specialization. Others focus on whether the claim can be substantiated.
  • Phrases such as "practice focused on" or "we handle" usually describe a practice without implying certification.

This matters for SEO too. Agencies often push the word "expert" into page titles and headings because it appears in search queries. Find a compliant phrasing instead. Search engines understand that "DUI defense lawyer in Tampa" answers a search for "DUI expert Tampa", so you lose little by using careful language. The same applies to attorney bio pages and directory profiles, which often carry the riskiest wording because nobody reviews them.

Lists of "super lawyers" or "best lawyers" designations raise a related question. Many states allow references to such recognitions if the claim is accurate, the awarding organization is named and the basis for selection is available. Some require a disclaimer that the designation is not issued by a court or the bar. Check before you add a badge to the header.

Testimonials, reviews and endorsements

Most states now permit client testimonials in some form, but conditions vary widely. A testimonial about results is treated like a past results claim. A testimonial that compares the firm to others may need to be substantiated. Some states require disclaimers, and some restrict testimonials from current clients or paid endorsers.

Rules that apply almost everywhere:

  • Never fabricate or edit a review so it says something the client did not say.
  • Do not pay for reviews or offer anything of value in exchange. Rule 7.2(b) limits giving anything of value for a recommendation, and Google's own review policies also prohibit incentives.
  • Disclose material connections. If an endorser is a relative, employee or paid actor, say so. Dramatizations should be labeled.
  • Respond carefully to reviews. Replying to a negative review must not reveal confidential information. Our guide to reviews and local SEO covers how to ask for and respond to reviews safely.

Asking satisfied clients for an honest review is generally fine. Asking only happy clients is a common practice, though some platforms discourage selective requests. Keep requests consistent and simple.

Ghost-written content and influencer posts follow the same logic. If a marketing vendor writes a post that appears to come from a client, or pays someone to praise the firm on social media without disclosure, the firm is responsible for it. Federal consumer protection guidance on endorsements points the same direction: disclose material connections clearly.

States that ask for more

Several large states add duties beyond the Model Rules. The examples below are summaries meant to show how far rules can differ. Read the current text before acting, because these rules are amended often.

StateExamples of added requirements
TexasMany advertisements must be filed with the State Bar's Advertising Review Committee, with a fee, unless an exemption applies. Specific rules govern statements about certification.
FloridaDetailed rules on what ads may contain, including limits on results and testimonials, plus filing for review of many advertisements. Florida also regulates descriptive statements and certain visual elements.
New YorkMany advertisements must carry the label "Attorney Advertising", and past results generally need a disclaimer. Copies of ads must be retained for set periods.

Other states have their own variations, including rules on trade names, solicitation letters after accidents and waiting periods for contacting victims. If your firm practices in several states, apply the strictest applicable rule to shared materials such as your homepage, national ads and social profiles.

Paid channels need the same review. Text in PPC ads is short, which tempts writers toward superlatives and guarantees. Run ad copy through the same checklist as your website.

A review process that fits a busy firm

Compliance gets easier when it is a routine rather than a reaction. A light process covers most firms.

  1. Name a responsible lawyer. Rule 7.2 requires a responsible lawyer or firm to be identified in advertising. Give that person final sign-off on new marketing material.
  2. Write a short style sheet. List banned words, approved descriptions of each practice, required disclaimers and how to present results. Share it with every vendor.
  3. Review before publishing. New pages, ads, videos, emails and social posts go through the responsible lawyer. Small edits to existing approved copy can follow the style sheet.
  4. Audit once a year. Read the whole website, directory profiles and active ads. Old pages written by former vendors often hold the riskiest claims.
  5. Keep records. Save dated copies of ads and major page versions, especially if your state requires retention.

Remember that the website is not the only channel. Video scripts, podcast appearances and newsletters count as communications about your services too. Our posts on video marketing and email newsletters cover channel-specific points, such as labeling dramatizations and keeping prospect outreach within Rule 7.3.

Treat vendor contracts as part of the process. Agreements with marketing agencies, lead generation services and answering services should require them to follow your style sheet and to submit material for approval. Be careful with lead generation arrangements in particular. Rule 7.2(b) limits paying for recommendations, and some lead services operate in ways that raise referral fee concerns. Ask your ethics counsel to review any pay-per-lead or pay-per-case arrangement before you sign.

Questions, answered

Can a lawyer call themselves an expert on their website?

It depends on the state. Model Rule 7.2(c) limits claims of certification as a specialist unless the lawyer is certified by an approved organization that is named. Some states treat expert as an implied specialist claim. Safer phrasing describes the practice focus instead.

Do we need a disclaimer when posting case results?

Often yes. The comments to Model Rule 7.1 warn that past results can create unjustified expectations, and several states, including New York, require disclaimers. Add context about each case, a clear statement that results vary and client consent where details are identifiable.

Are client testimonials allowed in lawyer advertising?

Most states allow them with conditions. Testimonials must be genuine, not paid for and not misleading. Some states require disclaimers or limit testimonials about results. Check your state's rule and keep records showing each testimonial is authentic.

Do ethics rules apply to Google Ads and social media posts?

Yes. Any communication about a lawyer's services is covered, including search ads, social posts, videos, directory profiles and email. Short formats tempt writers toward superlatives and guarantees, so review them with the same care as your website.

If we practice in several states, whose rules apply?

Choice of rule questions can be complex and are covered by Model Rule 8.5 and state versions. A practical approach is to follow the strictest applicable state for shared materials such as the homepage and national campaigns. Ask your ethics counsel for specific cases.

Ready when you are

One page, one fix, one week at a time. Start with the playbook that matches your next problem.

Read the playbook