Web design

Accessible law firm websitesA working guide to WCAG 2.2 AA

An accessible site lets every prospective client read your pages, use your forms and call you. It also lowers a legal risk that law firms, of all businesses, should take seriously.

By the Array Law editorsUpdated Nov 6, 20267 min read
Accessible law firm websites illustration
4.5:1
minimum contrast for body text
24×24 px
minimum target size in WCAG 2.2
Oct 2023
WCAG 2.2 published

Key takeaways

  • WCAG 2.2 Level AA is the practical target for a law firm site in 2026.
  • Most failures are basic: contrast, missing labels, keyboard traps and unclear links.
  • Automated scanners find only part of the problems. Test by keyboard and screen reader too.
  • Overlay widgets do not fix the underlying code.

Why accessibility matters for a law firm

This post is general information, not legal advice. For an opinion on your own exposure, talk to counsel who handles ADA matters.

Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act lists the office of a lawyer among places of public accommodation. The Department of Justice has said that businesses open to the public should make their websites accessible. It has not issued a specific technical rule for private businesses. Its 2024 rule naming WCAG 2.1 AA applies to state and local governments, not private firms.

In practice, demand letters and lawsuits about website accessibility are common in many states, and courts have reached different results. Most remediation plans point to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines because they are the accepted measure.

There is also a simpler reason. People with low vision, motor impairments or cognitive disabilities need lawyers too. If they cannot use your contact form, they will call another firm.

What WCAG 2.2 AA adds

WCAG 2.2 became a W3C Recommendation in October 2023. It keeps nearly everything from 2.1 and adds new success criteria. The ones at levels A and AA that matter most for law firm sites are:

  • Focus not obscured. A sticky header or chat bubble must not hide the element that has keyboard focus.
  • Target size. Buttons and links should be at least 24 by 24 CSS pixels, or have enough space around them.
  • Dragging movements. Anything that needs dragging, such as a slider, needs a simple click alternative.
  • Consistent help. If you offer a phone number or contact link on many pages, keep it in the same place.
  • Redundant entry. Do not ask for the same information twice in one process.
  • Accessible authentication. Client portals should not depend on memory puzzles. Allow password managers and paste.

Meeting 2.2 AA also meets 2.1 AA, so it is the sensible target for any rebuild.

Common failures on law firm sites

In our reviews of law firm websites, the same problems appear again and again:

  1. Low contrast. Light gray text on white, or white text on a photo. Body text needs a contrast ratio of at least 4.5:1, and large text 3:1.
  2. Unlabeled form fields. Placeholder text that disappears is not a label. Each field needs a visible, programmatic label.
  3. Vague links. "Learn more" repeated ten times tells a screen reader user nothing.
  4. Missing alt text. Attorney headshots and badges need short, accurate descriptions. Decorative images need empty alt text.
  5. Keyboard traps. Pop-ups, chat windows and mobile menus that cannot be closed with the keyboard.
  6. Autoplay video. Hero videos without pause controls or captions.
  7. Heading chaos. Headings chosen for size rather than structure.

Most of these are cheap to fix during a redesign and expensive to retrofit. Our law firm website design guide covers how to plan for them early.

How to test your site

Automated tools are a good start, but they catch only a portion of WCAG issues. Combine them with manual checks.

Automated

Run Lighthouse in Chrome DevTools, or a browser extension built on the axe engine, on your home page, a practice area page, a blog post and your contact page. Fix every error before moving on.

Keyboard

Put the mouse away. Press Tab through each page. You should always see where focus is, reach every link and button, open and close the menu, and submit the form.

Screen reader

Use VoiceOver on a Mac or iPhone, or NVDA on Windows. Listen to your contact form and one practice page. Note anything confusing.

Zoom and mobile

Zoom to 200 percent and check that nothing overlaps or gets cut off. Then test on a phone. The free web.dev accessibility course explains each check in more detail.

Where to start if your budget is tight

You do not need to fix everything at once. Start where prospects try to reach you, because those pages carry the most risk and the most value.

  1. Contact page and forms. Labels, error messages, keyboard access and a visible focus state.
  2. Header and navigation. The mobile menu, the phone link and the skip-to-content link.
  3. Home page. Contrast, headings, alt text and any video or carousel.
  4. Top practice area pages. The pages that bring in the most consultations.
  5. Templates for blog posts and attorney bios. Fix once, apply everywhere.

Keep a dated log of what you tested, what you found and what you fixed. If a demand letter arrives, a record of ongoing good-faith work is useful context for your counsel.

Why overlays are not a fix

Overlay widgets promise compliance with a single script. They cannot repair missing labels, broken heading structure or inaccessible forms in your code, and many screen reader users find them get in the way.

In 2025 the Federal Trade Commission finalized an order requiring one overlay vendor, accessiBe, to pay $1 million over claims that its tool could make any site WCAG compliant. A widget on your site is not a defense if the pages underneath fail.

Put that budget into fixing templates. Because most law firm sites reuse a handful of page types, a fix to one template often corrects dozens of pages at once.

Keep it accessible after launch

Accessibility slips when new content goes up. A blog post with a chart and no description, or a new landing page with a gray button, can undo good work.

  • Write a one-page checklist for anyone who publishes content.
  • Re-test key templates every quarter and after any redesign.
  • Publish an accessibility statement with a contact method for people who hit a barrier.
  • Respond to those reports quickly and log what you fixed.

Accessible pages also tend to load and read better on phones. That overlaps with the work in our guides on mobile websites and page experience.

Questions, answered

Does the ADA apply to my law firm's website?

The ADA covers law offices as public accommodations, and the Department of Justice has said websites of businesses open to the public should be accessible. Courts differ on details. This is not legal advice, so consult counsel about your firm's specific situation.

Should we target WCAG 2.1 or 2.2?

Target WCAG 2.2 Level AA. It includes the 2.1 criteria and adds a few more, such as target size and focus visibility. Meeting 2.2 AA therefore also satisfies any request or agreement that names 2.1 AA.

Will an accessibility widget protect us from lawsuits?

No widget can guarantee compliance. Overlays do not fix the underlying code, and the FTC has penalized a vendor for claiming otherwise. Firms with overlays still receive demand letters. Fixing your templates is the reliable path.

How often should we test for accessibility?

Test key templates at least quarterly, before and after any redesign, and whenever you add a new type of page or form. Train content editors on alt text, link wording and headings so new posts do not introduce fresh barriers.

Ready when you are

One page, one fix, one week at a time. Start with the playbook that matches your next problem.

Read the playbook